Paint is only as good as the prep underneath it, so the painter matters more than the color. These six companies work in York County, from the city out to Dover. They are listed in no ranked order, and every detail below comes from the company’s own website or Google Business Profile, checked on November 5 and 6, 2026.
Ausherman Painting

Painting York homes since 1979
Ausherman Painting says it has served homeowners and businesses since 1979. The York office is on West Market Street, and a second office is in Mechanicsburg. It does interior and exterior painting, cabinet painting, wallpaper removal, drywall repair, limewashing, light carpentry and color consultation, plus commercial work for offices and places of worship. Estimates are free, and its site says the company is donating labor to restore the York County Fire Museum.
Address: 1950 W Market St, York, PA 17404 Phone: (717) 843-4605 Website: aushermanpainting.com
Property Painting & Remodeling, LLC

Painting and pressure washing, with online quotes
Property Painting & Remodeling is on East Market Street in York and does interior and exterior painting for homes and businesses, along with pressure washing and cleaning services. The site lets you request an on-site quote online or book a pressure washing job with live pricing and a scheduled appointment, which is rare for a painter. If you want the siding washed before it is painted, it can handle both.
Address: 3110 E Market St Ste E, York, PA 17402 Phone: (717) 747-4618 Website: propertypaintingremodeling.com
Todd Hess Painting

Interior and exterior painting from North York
Todd Hess Painting is on North Sherman Street in York and does interior and exterior painting for homes and businesses in York and the surrounding communities. Customer reviews on its site mention drywall repair done before painting and stair railing work, and they describe a crew that is careful about cleanup. You can request a free estimate on the site.
Address: 2406 N Sherman St, York, PA 17406 Phone: (717) 881-5807 Website: toddahesspaintingco.com
Set The Tone Painting

A small crew in Dover, in business since 2020
Set The Tone Painting is a locally owned company in Dover that has been in business since 2020, and says its crew has more than 20 years of combined painting experience. It handles interior and exterior painting, deck and fence painting, drywall repair and trim work for homes and commercial customers. It bases its price on square footage, walks you through the scope first and offers free estimates.
Address: 3410 Longwood Ct, Dover, PA 17315 Phone: (717) 645-5049 Website: setthetonepaintingpa.com
Deardorff’s Painting & Pressure Washing

Owner on every job, painting since 2000
Deardorff’s is owned and operated by Bryan Deardorff, who lives in York and says he has painted for over 20 years and is present on every job. The shop on North Williams Street does interior and exterior painting and staining, applied by brush, roller or spray, along with pressure washing of decks, sidewalks and houses. It also does small drywall repairs, caulking and wallpaper removal. Call or text the number below.
Address: 404 N Williams St, York, PA 17404 Phone: (717) 487-7868 Website: deardorffpaint.com
Esteem Painting

Interior, exterior and cabinet painting
Esteem Painting says it is licensed and insured and works across York, Harrisburg, Mechanicsburg and Hershey. It does interior, exterior and commercial painting, cabinet painting and refinishing, deck staining, and color consultation, and it advertises low-VOC and zero-VOC paint options. Free estimates are offered on the site.
Address: 211 Pauline Dr #1123, York, PA 17402 Phone: (717) 204-8511 Website: esteempainting.com
What York’s Housing and Weather Mean for Your Paint Job
Lead paint in older York houses
York’s historic core is full of brick rowhouses and Victorians that city preservation guidance dates mostly to about 1870 to 1910, and plenty of county homes are older than 1978. The EPA’s lead-safe renovation rule covers paid work that disturbs paint in housing built before 1978. It says anyone paid for that work must be certified in lead-safe work practices, and that includes sole proprietors. So in an older house, ask directly whether the company is a certified lead-safe firm before sanding, scraping or cutting into painted trim.
Ask to see the certification. A painter who says it does not apply because the job is small should be asked how they will contain the dust.
Weather decides when you can paint
York’s July normals are a high near 87°F and a low near 63°F, and January lows sit near 21°F (climate data). Exterior paint needs temperatures and dry weather within a range the manufacturer sets on the can, so the practical window for exterior work in York County is spring and fall. A painter who offers to do exterior work in January should be asked what product they are using and what it is rated for.
Moisture and masonry
With about 43 inches of precipitation a year and flooding named the most frequent and costly hazard in the state by the county’s hazard mitigation plan, damp basement walls are common in the stone and brick houses downtown. Paint over a damp wall peels. Ask the painter to flag moisture before covering it, and to tell you what they plan to do about the source. Painting a basement wall is not radon mitigation, so if the room is going to be used, test it with a radon test either way.
Registration and the written contract
Pennsylvania’s home improvement law is the main protection you have here. According to the Attorney General’s office, contractors who do $5,000 or more of home improvement work a year must register, and the registration number has to appear on contracts, estimates, proposals and advertisements. Any job over $500 needs a written contract, and a contractor may not take payment before that contract is signed. A contract that leaves out information the law requires is not enforceable against you. You can check a registration at attorneygeneral.gov or by calling 1-888-520-6680, and it takes two minutes.
Before You Book
Get the scope in writing, including how much prep, how many coats and which brand and finish of paint will be used. Ask who is responsible for moving furniture and covering floors.
Sources: U.S. EPA lead-safe renovation rule, usclimatedata.com (1991 to 2020 normals), York County Hazard Mitigation Plan Update (2018), Pennsylvania Office of Attorney General home improvement contractor brochure (2025). Company details come from each company’s own website or Google Business Profile.
